Quantcast
Channel: Are opinion-based comments regarding the complexity of an answer constructive? - Meta Stack Overflow
Browsing all 4 articles
Browse latest View live

Answer by Laurel for Are opinion-based comments regarding the complexity of...

Most of the time, these comments point out something very obvious. This would make them fall under "does not add anything constructive/new"I often see the same type of comment on one-liners:This is...

View Article



Answer by Glorfindel for Are opinion-based comments regarding the complexity...

Isn't it ironic? On Meta, we see people asking to require a comment when you downvote every single day, and now there's a comment which could specify a possible reason for downvoting*, and somebody is...

View Article

Answer by user000001 for Are opinion-based comments regarding the complexity...

In my opinion the comments are constructive. They are criticizing the validity and the efficiency of the answer, which is entirely appropriate for a comment.

View Article

Are opinion-based comments regarding the complexity of an answer constructive?

I know our moderators are busy folks and I really don't want to make unnecessary work for them, so I would like some clarification regarding the "not constructive" comment flag.I recently flagged two...

View Article
Browsing all 4 articles
Browse latest View live




Latest Images